Process
Why three quotes never match (and it's not the prices)
When three subcontractor quotes come back wildly different, the usual culprit isn't the rates — it's that each trade measured the job differently. Here's how to fix the comparison.
Insights Published · 5 min · By Scaleline
For Australian builders of new homes.
Three quotes for the same job rarely line up because each trade measured a different quantity — not because one subbie is dearer than another. Until every quote is priced against one identical set of numbers, you’re comparing three different jobs. The fix is to measure once, then send the same quantities to each trade.
Everyone measures a different job
When each trade takes off the drawings themselves, they each make their own assumptions. One counts the garage walls, one doesn’t. One allows for 10% waste on cladding, one allows 5% waste. One reads the slab off the architectural, one off the structural. By the time three people have each measured independently, you’re not comparing three prices for one job — you’re comparing three different jobs.
That’s not dishonesty. It’s the inevitable result of measuring being done three times, three ways.
Comparability comes from the measurements, not the judgement
The fix isn’t to haggle the high quote down to the low one. It’s to give every trade the same quantities to price. When the scope and the numbers are identical, the only thing left varying is the rate — which is exactly the thing you actually want to compare.
This is the whole reason we keep measuring and pricing separate. We measure once, to one standard, with every line sourced to the drawing. The trades then price that — the same inclusions and exclusions, the same quantities. The comparison becomes real:
- Same measurements to every trade.
- We don’t rank, score or recommend — every quote comes to you.
- You price it, or the trades do. We never set a rate.
What this means for your margin
A quote you can’t trust the comparison on is a quote you have to pad. When the quantities are neutral and identical, you can hold a tighter number with more confidence — because you know the variance you’re seeing is price, not measuring noise.
Want to see it on your own numbers? Compare your three quotes →, see a sample report →, or send us a set of plans →.
This is Scaleline’s view. We measure residential jobs from drawings — we don’t price them, and we don’t sell software. Where we mention how we work, it’s to be useful, not to oversell.